Cost accounting sounds like a textbook but decides very concrete questions every day: at what price do we accept the order? Is the product still worth it? Do we make or buy? The answer often depends on which glasses you put on – full costing or marginal costing.
Full costing
Full costing allocates all costs to products – including fixed costs like rent, administration or depreciation. It uses overhead rates or allocation keys. The result is a unit price that has to cover all costs in the long run.
It is indispensable for the long-term price floor and for valuing inventory in the balance sheet. Its problem: allocating fixed costs is always somewhat arbitrary – and easily misleads short-term decisions.
Marginal costing
Marginal costing – usually as contribution margin accounting – assigns to products only the costs they actually cause: the variable costs. What is left is the contribution margin. It shows how much each product contributes to covering fixed costs.
Operating result = sum of contribution margins − fixed costs
The example that explains everything
A company has three products and €40k fixed costs, allocated by revenue:
| €k | A | B | C | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 100 | 80 | 50 | 230 |
| Variable costs | −60 | −70 | −55 | −185 |
| Contribution margin | 40 | 10 | −5 | 45 |
| Fixed costs (allocated by revenue) | −17.4 | −13.9 | −8.7 | −40 |
| Result, full costing | 22.6 | −3.9 | −13.7 | 5 |
Full costing says: B and C make a loss. So do we drop both?
- Drop B: the fixed costs remain (rent and administration continue). €10k contribution margin is lost. New result: 40 − 5 − 40 = −€5k. Worse!
- Drop C: a negative contribution margin disappears. New result: 40 + 10 − 40 = +€10k. Better!
Marginal costing gives the right answer: B contributes to covering fixed costs and should stay. Only C destroys money – every unit sold makes the result worse.
Which method when?
| Question | Suitable method |
|---|---|
| Accept an extra order with spare capacity? | Marginal costing (price above variable costs?) |
| Remove a product from the range? | Marginal costing, plus fixed costs that go away |
| Long-term price floor? | Full costing |
| Inventory valuation in the balance sheet? | Full costing (production costs) |
| Make or buy? | Marginal costing plus avoidable fixed costs |
Multi-level contribution margin accounting
A middle way is multi-level contribution margin accounting. Fixed costs are not allocated across the board but assigned to the level where they arise: product fixed costs (e.g. a special tool), product group fixed costs (a product manager), division fixed costs (a production hall) and company fixed costs (management). This shows from which level dropping something actually saves costs.
Conclusion
Full costs say what a product must cost in the long run. Marginal costs say what a decision actually does today. If you know both and use them deliberately, you make better pricing and product range decisions. Try it right away with the break-even calculator.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between full and marginal costing?
Full costing allocates all costs including fixed costs to products. Marginal costing assigns only variable costs and works with the contribution margin.
What does a negative contribution margin mean?
The selling price doesn't even cover the variable costs. Every additional unit sold makes the result worse.
Why do you still need full costing?
For the long-term price floor and for valuing inventory. In the long run, all costs have to be covered.