An investment fund pools the money of many investors and invests it in numerous securities. This creates diversification that is hard to achieve with individual stocks. When it comes to how securities are selected, however, there are two fundamentally different approaches.
Actively managed fund
A fund manager deliberately selects stocks or bonds, aiming to beat a benchmark index. That requires analysts, research and trading – which costs money. Ongoing charges of around 1–2% per year are typical, often plus an entry charge.
ETF (exchange-traded fund)
An ETF simply replicates an index, for example a global stock index. There are no selection decisions and hardly any staff costs. Ongoing charges are often 0.1–0.5% per year. ETFs are traded on the stock exchange like shares.
| Active fund | ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Beat the index | Track the index |
| Ongoing charges | usually 1–2% p.a. | usually 0.1–0.5% p.a. |
| Entry charge | common | no (only trading fee) |
| Transparency | holdings partly delayed | index is known |
| Chance of outperformance | yes, but uncertain | no – market return minus costs |
What research says
Numerous long-term studies show that over 10 to 15 years only a minority of active funds manage to beat their benchmark after costs. And which funds those will be is hard to predict in advance. The main reason is simple: costs are certain every year, outperformance is not.
How strongly costs work
€10,000 over 20 years at a 7% gross return per year:
| Ongoing charges | Final value |
|---|---|
| no costs | €38,697 |
| 0.2% p.a. (typical ETF) | €37,276 |
| 1.8% p.a. (typical active fund) | €27,562 |
The difference of almost €10,000 arises from costs alone – the active fund would have to be 1.6 percentage points better every year just to break even. More detail in Understanding fund costs.
When an active fund can still make sense
- In narrow markets that an index represents poorly.
- If you want a specific strategy that isn't available as an ETF.
- If costs are low and the fund has convinced over a long period in a traceable way.
Conclusion
For long-term wealth building, broadly diversified low-cost ETFs are a solid foundation for most investors. Active funds are not a mistake, but they have to reliably earn their higher costs – and only a few succeed.
Frequently asked questions
Is an ETF safer than an active fund?
Not automatically. Both fluctuate with the market they invest in. An ETF on a broad global index, however, is usually more diversified and cheaper.
What is an index?
An index tracks the performance of a defined group of securities, such as the largest companies of a country or the world.
Can an ETF go bankrupt?
In many countries fund assets are held separately from the assets of the fund company. The price risk of the securities held, however, remains.