At the end of the 1960s the Boston Consulting Group developed a picture that still appears in almost every strategy book: a matrix with four boxes and four animals – or at least three animals and a question mark. Its strength is simplicity. In ten minutes you can see whether a product portfolio is balanced or whether the company lives off a single cash cow.
The two axes
Vertical: market growth. How fast is the market in which the product is sold growing? Growth stands for attractiveness, but also for investment needs.
Horizontal: relative market share. Your own market share divided by that of the largest competitor. A value above 1 means: we are the market leader. Behind this lies the experience curve effect – whoever produces more tends to have lower unit costs.
The horizontal dividing line is usually at 1.0. Vertically, the average market growth of the industry or a value around 10% is often used – what matters is setting the threshold once and applying it to all products equally.
The four quadrants and their standard strategies
The idea is a cycle: cash cows fund question marks, which become stars, which – once the market matures – eventually become cash cows themselves.
A worked example
| Product | Market growth | Own share | Strongest competitor | Rel. share | Quadrant |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A – Standard pump | 2% | 30% | 20% | 1.5 | Cash cow |
| B – Smart control | 18% | 25% | 15% | 1.7 | Star |
| C – Solar module | 22% | 4% | 18% | 0.2 | Question mark |
| D – Legacy spare parts | −3% | 6% | 25% | 0.2 | Dog |
In the chart, each product is drawn as a circle whose size corresponds to its revenue. That way you see not only the position but also the weight in the portfolio.
Where the BCG matrix reaches its limits
- Market definition: whether you are the market leader depends on how narrowly you define the market. With a narrow definition, anyone can become a star.
- Only two dimensions: profitability, competitive intensity and synergies between products are missing.
- The experience curve doesn't apply everywhere: in niche or service markets, size does not automatically bring cost advantages.
- Standard strategies are not orders: they are a starting point for discussion, not its result.
If you need more dimensions, use the McKinsey matrix (market attractiveness and competitive strength, each with several weighted criteria). For a quick overview, the BCG matrix remains unbeatable.
How to use it in practice
- Group products or business units sensibly – not every item number on its own.
- Get market data: industry statistics, market studies, sales estimates.
- Set and document the thresholds.
- Draw the matrix, circle size by revenue.
- Cross-check with contribution margins and cash flows per quadrant.
- Make a decision for each quadrant and reflect it in the budget.
Conclusion
The BCG matrix is a conversation starter. It forces you to think about the future of every product and to direct money deliberately to where it creates growth. Combined with contribution margin and cash flow figures from controlling, the picture becomes a solid basis for decisions.
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate relative market share?
Divide your own market share by that of the largest competitor. If you are the market leader yourself, divide by the share of the second-largest player; the value is then above 1.
What is a cash cow?
A product with a high relative market share in a market that is barely growing. It generates more cash than it needs for investment and funds other areas.
What alternatives to the BCG matrix are there?
Well-known ones are the McKinsey matrix with weighted criteria and the product life cycle model. Many companies combine the BCG logic with their own contribution margin analyses.